Controversial Selection: Jessica Suggs Appointed Otero County Probate Judge Amid Public Scrutiny and Split Vote

In a decision that has reignited debate across Otero County, the Otero County Commission voted 2 to 1 this week to appoint Jessica Suggs as the new probate judge, marking her return to public office after a turbulent resignation from the magistrate court in 2023. The vote, held during a special meeting this month saw Commissioners Amy Barela, Vickie Marquardt, in favor, while Commissioner Gerald Matherly dissented.

Commissioner Matherly, who voted against the appointment, stated that the decision “should reflect the highest standards of public trust,” signaling concern over the precedent being set.

Suggs, formerly known as Jessica Turner, previously served as a New Mexico State Police officer and later as magistrate judge. Her tenure in both roles has been shadowed by a 2018 DWI incident that continues to raise questions about accountability, privilege, and public trust.

The 2018 DWI Controversy

On February 9, 2018, Turner was found slumped over the steering wheel of a white pickup truck parked off Highway 82 near Alamogordo. Deputies responding to a 911 call reported signs of intoxication, including slurred speech, swaying, and the smell of alcohol. Turner admitted to drinking wine and taking medications including Xanax, which carries warnings against operating vehicles.

Despite these observations, Turner was not arrested. Dashcam footage showed her struggling with field sobriety tests, and the truck’s engine was warm. A “dinging” sound consistent with keys in the ignition was captured on video, yet deputies cited lack of probable cause due to missing keys. Instead of being booked, Turner was given a ride home by fellow law enforcement officers.

The incident sparked public outrage, with critics alleging preferential treatment due to Turner’s law enforcement status. She was placed on paid leave and later resigned from the New Mexico State Police as the department moved to terminate her employment.

Prosecutors charged Turner with DWI and evidence tampering, but her defense argued she was not driving and had pulled over due to chest pains from an autoimmune condition. The case became a flashpoint for discussions about law enforcement accountability and judicial ethics, and the influence of good ole boy insiders within the local Republican Party, especially as Turner transitioned into a judicial role later that year.

Judicial Career and Resignation

Suggs was appointed magistrate judge in 2018 by Governor Susana Martinez and re-elected in 2022. She earned her law degree and was admitted to the New Mexico Bar in October 2022, positioning herself for continued legal service. However, she resigned abruptly in June 2023, just months into her new term. No formal reason was provided, though the resignation followed a period of heightened scrutiny and lingering public concern over her past.

Governor Michelle Lujan Grisham appointed Albert R. Greene III to fill the magistrate court vacancy following Suggs’ departure.

New Appointment as Probate Judge

The appointment this week of Suggs as probate judge has reignited community concerns and caused more questions of insider influencers and croninsim within the local Republican Party ranks and leadership of the Otero County Commission. While supporters cite her legal credentials and experience, critics question the optics of reinstating a figure with unresolved public trust issues sends the wrong message by the County Commissioner related to law and order.

Broader Scrutiny of Otero County Commission Leadership

The appointment comes amid growing scrutiny of Otero County leadership, particularly Commissioners Amy Barela and Vickie Marquardt, who voted in favor of Suggs. Marquardt is the sister-in-law of Otero County Sheriff David Black, a connection that has drawn criticism in light of the county’s handling of the Elijah Hadley case.

Hadley, a 19-year-old Alamogordo resident, was shot and killed by Otero County deputies vis 21 shots. The incident has sparked ongoing calls for accountability, with civil rights advocates and community members alleging excessive force and lack of oversight. The case may result in a multi-million dollar settlement, and watchdog groups have accused county commissioners of failing to hold the sheriff’s department accountable due to family connections snd cronyism.

The Justice for Elijah Hadley campaign continues to push for transparency, citing concerns over internal investigations and the absence of meaningful disciplinary action. Critics argue that the commissioners’ close ties to law enforcement—especially familial relationships—compromise impartial oversight and erode public trust. The case against the deputy involved and charged with murder is making its way through the courts.

Community Reaction to Suggs Appointment

Public response has been mixed. On social media and local forums, some residents expressed frustration:

“This sends the wrong message. We need judges who reflect integrity, not controversy.” - Facebook comment thread

"As expected Barela and Marquardt placed political favors and cronyism over public safety and trust." - Facebook Comment thread

"At least Matherly is honest and listened to community concerns. Matherly voted his conscious representing honesty and law and order." - Twitter Comment Thread

A few defended the appointment:

“She’s qualified, she’s served, and she’s earned a second chance. Let’s move forward.” — Facebook user comment

"Shouldn't we support second chances, maybe she learned her lessons and is rebuilding her reputation? - Twitter Comment

The narrow 2 to 1 vote underscores the community divide: a willingness by 2 commissioner to support Suggs regardless of her history, and a refusal by Matherly to overlook past controversies, placing ethics as the standard.

As AlamogordoTownNews.org continues to track appointments and civic leadership and with the upcoming municipal election, this decision invites broader reflection on redemption, transparency, and the standards we set for those who serve in positions of public trust.

Sources:

KRQE News – Jury deliberates in DWI trial for former State Police officer

KRQE News – Former NMSP officer asks judge to dismiss DWI case

2nd Life Media – Suggs Resigns Magistrate Court

Alamogordo Daily News – Commission appoints new probate judge

KTSM – State Police officer resigns after controversial DWI stop

Facebook threads

Twitter theads

More News from Alamogordo

• Alamogordo Rallies for Heroes Welcome: Honor Flight Returns September 27th Heros welcome home 1106 New York Avenue, beginning at 7:00 p.m. September 27th, 2025.
• Tigers Roar on Homecoming Night: Alamogordo Defeats Organ Mountain 34–14 Tigers roll to victory...