Suspect Matthew Weems Arrested for Murder in Alamogordo: Third Major Case in Ongoing Pattern of Local Homicides

In a chilling development that deepens concerns over violent crime in Alamogordo, the Otero County Sheriff’s Office has confirmed the arrest of Matthew Weems, age 31, in connection with a murder discovered during a welfare check on November 17, 2025. This marks the third major homicide investigation in the area within the past 18 months, echoing patterns previously reported by AlamogordoTownNews.org.

Welfare Check Leads to Murder Arrest

Deputies responded to a residence off 602 S. Florida following a welfare check request tied to a prior incident. Upon arrival, they discovered a deceased female inside the home. Evidence at the scene indicated foul play, prompting immediate involvement from the Major Crimes Unit—a multi-agency task force including investigators from the Otero County Sheriff’s Office, Alamogordo Police Department, Ruidoso Police Department, and Lincoln County Sheriff’s Office.

Matthew Weems was arrested on an open count of murder. Authorities have stated there are no additional suspects and no known threats to the public at this time. The investigation remains active, with further details to be released as permitted.

 Context: A Troubling Pattern of Violence

This arrest follows a disturbing series of fatal stabbings previously documented by AlamogordoTownNews.org in the August 2024 article, “Stabbing Murders in Alamogordo: Is a Pattern Developing?

That report highlighted two then unsolved cases:

 June 1, 2024: Severe Scott Bowman, age 65, was found dead from stab wounds in his home on 2nd Street.

 August 15, 2024: Lyman D. Hughes, a well-known local figure, was fatally stabbed. The Major Crimes Unit requested surveillance footage from residents near North Florida Avenue and Washington Avenue.

While Weems was NOT publicly linked to those earlier cases, his arrest adds weight to community concerns about in-home violence targeting vulnerable individuals.

Community Impact and Ongoing Investigation

Local residents have expressed renewed anxiety over public safety, especially in light of the proximity between the latest crime scene and prior incidents. The Sheriff’s Office urges anyone with relevant information to contact them at 575-437-2210.

As Alamogordo continues to grapple with these tragedies, the arrest of Matthew Weems may offer a turning point in restoring community trust and advancing justice.  Pressure is on the courts to hold the suspects and ensure community safety. Investigators remain committed to transparency with an increase in press releases from the sheriff’s office in the most recent month. We will follow as the case unfolds.

Sources:

2nd Life Media -

Stabbing Murders in Alamogordo: Is a Pattern Developing?”

2nd Life Media -Otero County Sheriff’s Office Public Information Release, November 17, 2025

2nd Life Media -Otero County Sheriff’s Office Public Information Release, November 20, 2025

More News from Alamogordo

• Suspicious Death Reported to Otero County Sheriff's Department Prompts Major Crimes Investigation A suspicious death discovered during a welfare check in Otero County has prompted an active investigation
• Kendall Redfearn of Alamogordo Arrested After Violent Assault on Elderly Parents Alamogordo Police Department (APD) responded to a violent assault..