Legal Costs Mount Across Alamogordo Institutions- How do Alamogordo Public Schools, Otero County and the City of Alamogordo Compare?

Alamogordo’s public institutions—City Hall, Otero County, and the Alamogordo Public School District—have collectively spent over $3.5 million on legal services, settlements, and court-related expenses over the past five years. The rising costs, driven by lawsuits, administrative disputes, and governance controversies especially within the Alamogordo Public Schools and within the County are prompting calls for greater transparency to the public and more dialogue around fiscal accountability by some citizens.

According to the New Mexico Muncipal League Cities general face higher legal costs due to the complexity of city operations. However the city of Alamogordo operates it legal budget within the norms of a typical city of its size within New Mexico. On the other hand Otero County and the Alamogordo Public School System runs moderate to hot in spending for legal issues and representation in comparision to their peer groups.

Cities are generally expected to carry higher legal costs than counties or school districts, and for good reason: the scope and complexity of municipal services is broader, more regulated, and more exposed to litigation risk.

Why Cities Typically Spend More on Legal Services

Cities manage a wide array of functions that trigger legal oversight:

• Law enforcement and public safety
• Code enforcement and zoning
• Utilities (water, sewer, sometimes electric)
• Public works and infrastructure
• Parks, recreation, and cultural programming
• Labor relations with unionized employees

Each of these areas can generate lawsuits, contract disputes, or regulatory compliance needs—requiring both in-house counsel and outside legal specialists.

2. Ordinance Enforcement

Cities routinely prosecute municipal code violations, requiring:

• Legal review of citations and appeals
• Defense against civil rights claims tied to enforcement
• Coordination with courts and administrative hearings

Counties and School Districts rarely engage in this kind of granular legal work.

Let's talk about the numbers in some granular detail and see how the local entities compare to state norms.

Otero County: Moderate Spending, High-Profile Cases

Otero County has spent an estimated $860,000 on legal services and settlements since FY 2020. While its annual legal budget averages $140K–$200K, spikes have occurred due to civil rights litigation and First Amendment disputes.

• In 2023, the county paid settle related to an ACLU lawsuit.
• The ongoing Williams v. Otero County case, alleging wrongful death and civil rights violations, may push future costs higher as well as litigation pending in a sheriffs related shooting death of a teenager. The expectation is a large settlement in each per legal scholars. Esposure in these two cases could be in the millions.
• Most settlements are paid through insurance carriers like the New Mexico Self-Insurer’s Fund, with estimated insurer payouts totaling $200K–$300K.

City of Alamogordo: Steady and Consistent Legal Investment and Spend

The City of Alamogordo shines as the best operating entity in relation the legal expenses when measured against state standards and maintains a consistent legal budget of $320K–$400K annually, totaling nearly $1.8 million over five years. This includes salaries for in-house counsel and fees for outside attorneys.

• Legal services account for ~0.55% of the city’s operating budget—typical for municipalities of similar size.
• Settlement costs have remained low, with insurer payouts estimated at $100K–$150K, mostly for minor tort claims and civil rights complaints.

Alamogordo Public Schools: Litigation-Heavy and Costly

Alamogordo Public Schools (APS) stands out with the highest legal exposure among local entities. APS when compared to its peer group of other comparable school systems ranks poorly. Over the past five years, APS has spent an estimated $800K–$1.1 million on legal fees, court costs, and settlements.

• Annual legal services range from $90K–$130K, but settlements—often tied to employment disputes and civil rights claims—have pushed totals higher.
• In 2023, APS received settlement influx of $29,165 from the national Juul/Altria settlement, earmarked for tobacco education.
• Insurer payouts for APS are estimated at at up to $400K more recently, reflecting repeated litigation and HR-related claims most recent to include a settlement to former Superintendent Pam Renteria.

How Our Local Governement Entities Compares to Statewide Norms

Below we compare our local government entities to peer districts, counties, and cities across New Mexico:

• APS ranks high in legal spending for a district of its size, exceeding the norm of $50K–$90K/year.
• Otero County’s legal costs are moderate, but volatile due to high-profile cases.
• City of Alamogordo’s legal budget is average, with stable year-over-year spending.

Most entities aim to keep legal costs under 0.3%–0.7% of their total operating budgets as a standard. Alamogordo Public Schools has exceeded 1.3%–1.6%, signaling elevated risk and potential governance concerns.

There’s no fixed “legal expense standard,” but most New Mexico entities aim to keep legal services under 0.3%–0.7% of their total operating budget. Here’s how local government stacks up:

Alamogordo Public Schools -percentage of budget spent on legal expenses ~1.3%–1.6% (high than average compared to peer group.) Higher than average due to repeated employment disputes, civil rights complaints, and board-related litigation. Most districts of similar size (e.g., Silver Consolidated, Deming, Artesia) spend closer to $60K–$90K/year.

Oter County - percentage of budget spent on legal expenses ~0.33%–0.38% (moderate compared to peer group) Moderate exposure to date, with spikes tied to First Amendment and wrongful death cases potentially leading to a huge spike. Counties like Lincoln, Eddy, and Sierra report similar legal costs but don't face the threat posed pending litigation.

City of Alamogordo - percentage of budget spent on legal expenses  ~0.53%–0.57% (within peer group range under state standard). Typical for its size, with steady legal services spend and low settlement volatility. Comparable to cities like Carlsbad, Roswell, and Farmington, which also budget ~$300K–$450K annually for legal counsel.

Legal expenditures are a necessary part of public governance—but when they begin to rival core service budgets or create significant exposure as in the case of Otero County with two pending case and Alamogordo Public Schools which is 2 times state norms, taxpayers deserve answers and clarity. Two of Alamogordo’s government institutions now face a pivotal moment: either embrace transparency and instutional reforms, or risk further erosion of public trust and more legal expenses costing taxpayer money that could be dedicated to direct services.

Citations

ACLU of New Mexico. “Otero County Resident Wins Settlement for Unlawful Silencing.” aclu-nm.org

Yahoo News. “Alamogordo Public School District Awarded Nearly $30,000 in Juul Settlement.” news.yahoo.com

2nd Life Media. “Alamogordo Public Schools: New School Board Settling Scores and Costing Taxpayers.” 2ndlifemediaalamogordo.town.news

Otero County Financial Reports. co.otero.nm.us

City of Alamogordo Budget Documents. ci.alamogordo.nm.us

Williams v. Otero County Board of Commissioners. Justia Dockets

Goodman v. City of Alamogordo. Justia Dockets

NM Governmental Conduct Act Compliance Guide. nmag.gov

More News from Alamogordo

• Shadows of Turnover: Alamogordo’s Decade of Dysfunction and the Rise of Acting City Manager, Dr. Stephanie Hernandez For a decade, the city manager’s office in Alamogordo, has been less a seat of governance than a revolving door..,
• Alamogordo Proud: Love INC of Otero County, A Non-Profit Ministry of Compassion, Led with Vision #Alamogordo Proud Spotlight Love Inc of Otero County under the leadership of ED Susan Payne