Image
Dr. Stephanie Hernandez says a city commission discussion this week over Mayor Sharon McDonald's role in the agenda process was "blown out of proportion," and that the mayor asked for nothing more than what city policy already calls for and has been established practice for years.
Hernandez made the remarks on her segment "The Dr. Is In" in conversation with Anthony Lucero. The full comments can be heard on KALHRadio.org.
The issue came before commissioners at Tuesday night's meeting after McDonald sent an email asking to review draft agendas with the city manager and city clerk before they are published
See related story:
Hernandez said she read the email as "a reasonable request to understand the issues and ask questions on behalf of the citizens she represents. Nothing more."
She pointed to Resolution 2018-08, which she said directs that the city clerk shall consult with the city manager and the mayor.
"Shall consult, not may consult, and not occasionally consult," Hernandez said. "This isn't new."
Hernandez said she has taken part in many agenda reviews herself and described them as brief and productive.
"No mayor ever approved or removed agenda items," she said. "They sought clarification and prepared themselves to lead an informed discussion."
She added that any commissioner who asked for the same opportunity was given it, even though the resolution does not require it. "That's just simple good communication and professional management," she said.
"So why has something we've done for years suddenly become controversial?"
Hernandez argued that because the mayor presides over commission meetings and represents the entire city, her job goes beyond running the meeting to understanding the issues and guiding the discussion.
She said there were times when McDonald appeared to be the only elected official who had thoroughly read the agenda reports beforehand, and that a standing agenda review on a set day and time is "simply good operational practice."
Hernandez said what she found "particularly troubling" was that the city manager indicated he did not appreciate the mayor's tone, but raised the matter before the full commission rather than with McDonald directly.
"If you disagree with someone's tone, especially one of your bosses, wouldn't the professional approach be to have a conversation?" she asked.
Instead, she said, something that could have been resolved between the manager and the mayor became a public discussion that "frankly felt more like an ambush."
Hernandez said the response pointed to "a clear alliance" on the commission that, in her view, seems more interested in challenging the mayor than working with her. She did not name individual commissioners.
She said McDonald repeatedly clarified during the meeting that she was not seeking additional authority or control over the agenda, but that "that narrative kept being pushed."
Hernandez closed by framing the dispute around residents.
"Everything done in local government is on behalf of the citizens," she said. "So why is helping the mayor become better informed to lead a more meaningful discussion on behalf of those citizens met with such resistance? That speaks volumes."
"We talk about leadership and collaboration," she added, "but those principles mean very little if we can't demonstrate them in something as basic as preparing for a meeting."
Dr. Stephanie Hernandez's full conversation with Anthony Lucero is available at KALHRadio.org and on YouTube per the link above in the article.