Alamogordo commission settles agenda dispute, but clash over city manager inquiry erupts
ALAMOGORDO — A months-long tug-of-war over the mayor's role in setting the City Commission's agenda ended quietly Tuesday night with a unanimous vote allowing her a seat at the table following past precedent and municipal league recommendations.
Then a vote to look into an anonymous complaint against City Manager Robert Stockwell first passed then turned the end of the meeting into an open confrontation between Stockwell and Mayor McDonald, with 5 of the men on the commission voting against an inquiry into the behavior of Mr Stockwell per an anonymous letter that was sent to multiple press outlets and the city of Alamogordo Commission by a staff member anonymously for justified fear of retaliation.
Mayor gets a seat at the agenda table
The agenda item, titled "Consider and act upon the mayor's role in city commission agenda process," was placed on the agenda by Stockwell, not the mayor. He said a memo from the mayor asking to review draft agendas, and to be consulted on any changes afterward, went beyond past practice and could keep items off the agenda when they came in late. In a long and heated debate the conversation moved forward.
The mayor read written statements from former Mayors Susan Payne and Susie Galea, former Mayor Pro Tem Nadia Sykes, and former City Manager Stephanie Hernandez. All of them described regular meetings where past mayors went over draft agendas before they were published. The mayor cited Resolution 2018-08, Rule 5A, which says the city clerk "shall consult with the city manager and mayor" when preparing the agenda.
"I am not asking to control the agenda, interfere with administrative duties, or prevent any commissioner from bringing forward an item," she said. She added that she had not been invited to an agenda meeting since Stockwell started on July 1.
Stockwell said he had no objection to the mayor attending staff's agenda review, held at 2 p.m. on the Tuesday before each meeting. He said the problem was the request to see draft items and backup material ahead of that meeting, and to approve changes after it. Staff noted that department heads often turn items in as late as Tuesday night, the day of the review.
Some commissioners questioned whether the mayor should have any extra role. Rardin noted that Alamogordo has a "weak mayor" form of government. "All seven of us sitting up here have the exact same authority," he said. Tapley and Tardin read the mayor's memo as a directive to the city manager, which she denied. "It was never meant to be a demand," she said.
The commission voted 7-0 for a motion by Commissioner Robinson, seconded by Commissioner Hernandez, that the mayor will attend the Tuesday 2 p.m. meeting to review the agenda only and follow the process that has been precedent for over a decade and if which Stockwell has not followed with an invitation to attend until the mayor requested it. The mayor will now attend the meetings per the vote of 7 to 0.
Vote on complaint against city manager sparks confrontation
After a closed executive session, the commission took up a complaint, brought forward by the mayor, about the city manager and the community development director. The commission directed Human Resources Director Michelle Osborne to have an independent party conduct a limited inquiry and report back at a future executive session.
Commissioner Burnett made the motion "as much as I don't want to do this," calling it due diligence. Mayor Pro Tem Rardin seconded it but called the inquiry "unwarranted due to the fact that it's anonymous." The motion first appeared to pass, 5-2.
Stockwell then asked to speak. He waived his right to have the matter kept in executive session and asked the mayor, "Who initiated this witch hunt?" He said he wanted to know exactly what he was accused of. He tied the complaint to an anonymous letter sent to commissioners on Oct. 5 that he said had been widely circulated and picked up by local media as the letter was sent to multiple local media outlets. Mr. Stockwell took offense the letter was reported in local press and that the mayor placed a discussion of rather to investigate it into the agenda.
This media outlet along with our sister radio station received a copy of the letter and reported that an accusation has been made concerning the city manager and a staff members’ behavior. This media outlet in order to protect the privacy of the director in question did not provide the name nor position of that director. That information was later leaked as a part of another complaint filed against the city and via staff members notifying the news outlet of inquiries as to rather they were offended by actions.
This media outlet provided a commentary based upon paid staff members of the city contacting us and ran a story with comment from Mr. Stockwell to ensure fairness in reporting.
The reporting included:
"The commission has one employee," Stockwell said. "Why didn't you sit down with me?" He called the letter "garbage" and questioned spending public money on a complaint from someone "not even willing to put their name behind something."
The mayor said she put the item on the agenda as due diligence, not as an accusation, which is exactly what the public expects for transparency purposes. She said HR had told her city employees cannot investigate the city manager, so the work would have to be done by an outside party. "If we're investigating the employees that serve you, you're not above that either," she said. Stockwell said she was linking unrelated matters.
Citing Rule 21 of the commission's rules, Rardin asked for a revote so he could change his vote to support the city manager. A longtime commissioner, Hernandez who served with Stockwell before also backed him, saying any concern with the city's one employee should be handled by sitting down with him "like adults."
What the mayor did by placing it on the agenda was exactly what the public would expect a discussion, proof of a discussion by it being placed on the agenda and transparency.
Five of the 6 men on the commission took offense to even having the discussion which was expected. The item was put to revote and 5 of the 7 commissioners voted to change their direction and not investigate Stockwell coming to his defense rather than allow an independent investigation.
Grievance, fairgrounds lot
Osborne told the commission that an independent reviewer looked at an employee grievance (that grievance was filed by former project manager Justen Boyle) that mentioned the city manager. The reviewer found no conflict of interest and said Stockwell can hear the grievance himself. That meeting is set for Thursday at noon with Mr Boyle who has been terminated by the city under questionable circumstances and who has potentially filed an FMLA and or EEOC complaint for wrongful termination.
The commission took no action on the sale of the fairgrounds parking lot, which was discussed in closed session.
City manager's report
Golf course: The city signed an agreement with Maximum Golf to take over running the golf course. The handoff happens in December and is to be finished by Dec. 31.
City attorney: Several months of recruiting did not produce a city attorney, so the city will issue a request for proposals to law firms in early December, open for 30 days. The mayor and two commissioners will sit on the review committee. Stockwell hopes to bring a contract to the commission by mid- to late January.
Projects: Fire Station No. 2 should be done once its driveways are paved, possibly by late next week.
The $2.2 million refurbishment of the Callahan water tank is complete
Bids for the (only major project to be released under Stockwell’s leadership since assuming the helm on July 1st), the Alamo Aquatic Center will close Dec. 15.
Coming soon: A billboard ordinance should come to the commission within about a month. An extraterritorial jurisdiction ordinance and the drainage master plan are expected in January. The "Let's Grow Alamo" comprehensive plan is on schedule for spring 2027.
Streets: Staff has started talks with the state Department of Transportation about having the state rebuild White Sands Boulevard and then hand it over to the city.
A road survey found Alamogordo's streets are in typical condition for U.S. cities. "Our roads are bad, but the good news is, everybody else's are bad too," Stockwell said making light of the nation’s infrastructure failures.
The referenced survey has not been released to the public but an IPRA has been filed seeking what Mr. Stockwell referenced.
If the survey Stockwell referenced was a prior survey from 2022 it supports viewing Alamogordo’s roads as average/typical for a city its size—meaning the problems are real and shared with many other communities, driven by funding and maintenance realities—while New Mexico as a state is on the weaker end of U.S. rankings. The city’s 2022 assessment provides the local data foundation, and TRIP reports supply the strongest comparative state/national context. Specific block-by-block or exact PCI numbers would require the full city report or commission presentation materials of which were not released as a part of the city mangers report.
A traffic study is underway on whether to close the Mountain View Bridge as part of the Oregon Avenue Phase Two project.
Bonita Lake: The lake remains open for fishing, but other access is limited because of runoff and debris. Stockwell said shoreline access should be safe by next summer, with long-term decisions involving Lincoln County and the state still a couple of years away.
The commission also unanimously combined its two December meetings into one on Dec. 8.
Public comment
Resident Russell Davis said the restored Dudley School in Chihuahuita is still not open as a true community center. Its kitchen is unfinished, and it is not listed on the city's website.
In response, one commissioner said most of the commission had never been allowed to use the building, and Stockwell said it is now available to anyone who requests it.
Beth Crab criticized the agenda of the agenda discussion debate and the mayors role as a waste of time and that the city needs to manage under past precedent. She also questioned paying a city manager about $200,000 a year when the city's interim manager had cost much less.
The meeting adjourned abruptly with several of the male commissioners visibly agitated by the tone and questioning of a city manager in a defensive position as city infrastructure projects continue to be delayed without question by a majority of the commissioners.
More News from Alamogordo
- Before tonight's vote, municipal league guidance weighs in on Alamogordo agenda dispute Statewide clerks' column says the mayor runs the meeting and questions the "approve the agenda" vote — but leaves the drafting question to local rules
- FEMA and FCC Conduct Nationwide Emergency Alert System Test Today at 12:20 p.m. MT Only a test…