Image
ALAMOGORDO, N.M. — When the Alamogordo City Commission takes up the question of Mayor Sharon McDonald's role in building meeting agendas tonight, commissioners will have more than the city's own procedural rules to consider. Guidance published by the New Mexico Municipal League speaks directly to two of the arguments in the dispute.
The commission meets at 6:30 p.m. in the Donald E. Carroll City Commission Chambers at City Hall, 1376 E. Ninth St.
As Alamogordo Town News reported Saturday, City Manager Robert Stockwell has asked commissioners to clarify Rule 5(a) of Resolution 2018-08, the commission's meeting procedures. The rule says the city clerk "shall consult with the City Manager and the Mayor" when preparing agendas, but it says nothing about timing, form or whether the mayor approves drafts.
McDonald has asked City Clerk Rachel Hughs and Stockwell for a preliminary draft of each agenda, time to review it and meet with them before publication, and a say in any later removal or significant change. She has written that the request is about being prepared as presiding officer, not about interfering with administration, and she has not claimed veto power over items.
Stockwell says the extra review step would push the staff deadline for agenda items from noon Tuesday back to the previous Friday. He says earlier mayors sometimes sat in on agenda reviews but never held approval authority. Our research in speaking with previous city managers and mayors show the previous 4 mayors and city managers reviewed the agenda prior to publication with the mayor either by email or in person and they did it under the present timeframe as precedent. If Mr Stockwell cannot manage timelines established over 4 past administrations then his time management skills need evaluated. His closed door evaluations by the commission each quarter need to be made public as well.
Stockwell also points out that the full commission votes to adopt the agenda at the start of every meeting, this is counter to municipal league guidance.
McDonald says pre-publication meetings were routine under former mayors Susie Galea, Richard Boss and Susan Payne, and Payne has backed her account, though not always via in person meetings.
The New Mexico Municipal League's newsletter, The Municipal Reporter, runs an "Ask a Clerk" column for clerks and local officials.
One 2025 column answered whether a governing body needs an agenda item to approve its own agenda. The League's answer was no.
The column made three points that bear on tonight's discussion:
The agenda vote may not be the safeguard it appears to be. The column says a standing "approval of agenda" item is unnecessary and runs contrary to the New Mexico Open Meetings Act. Under that law, the agenda must be prepared and made public at least 72 hours before the meeting, and some matters, such as zoning hearings, require published or mailed notice even earlier. The column asks what a governing body would do if its agenda-approval motion failed after notices had gone out and residents had shown up. Alamogordo's agendas include an "Approval of Agenda" item, and Stockwell has cited that vote as the commission's check on the agenda.
The mayor runs the meeting. The column says state law makes the mayor the presiding officer of governing body meetings in every form of municipal government. That gives the mayor authority to move items around on the agenda during the meeting so it runs efficiently. Some cities, the column notes, keep the agenda-approval item mainly so items can be rearranged, which it says the mayor can already do.
Local rules govern the details. The column says many cities spell out agenda creation and approval in their own rules of procedure, and that cities with adopted rules should follow them as written.
The column closes by citing Robert's Rules of Order in Brief, 3rd edition, which describes the presiding officer as the person who keeps order, enforces the rules and decides who speaks.
The League column addresses the mayor's authority during a meeting. It does not say whether a mayor should review agenda drafts before they are published, which is the heart of the Alamogordo disagreement.
On that point, the column's own advice sends the question back home. Alamogordo has adopted rules, and Rule 5(a) requires the clerk to consult the mayor. The question before commissioners is what "consult" means: Stockwell's narrower reading, in which existing manager-clerk review already satisfies the rule, or a broader more recognized reading statewide is that it gives the mayor input while the agenda is being drafted.
Stockwell has said that if the commission finds McDonald's request appropriate, Rule 5(a) should be amended to spell out the process.
State statute adds context on both sides. Under NMSA 3-14-10, the mayor presides and carries out duties the commission assigns, with a commissioner's powers and vote, but no separate administrative authority. Daily administration belongs to the city manager under NMSA 3-14-13 and 3-14-14.
The city charter, Article VIII, Section 2, names the mayor presiding officer and the representative and voice of the city.
The League offers help to cities working through these questions. Its contact for the topic is Rebecca Martinez at rmartinez@nmml.org or 505-690-3278.
Closed-door complaint. Commissioners will go into executive session to consider a complaint concerning Stockwell and Community Development Director Shelley Dowhanik-Baron, an item McDonald placed on the agenda. A possible open-session vote could authorize an independent investigation. The packet does not identify the complainant or the allegations.
Fairgrounds parking lot. A closed session on the possible sale of the property, with a possible vote afterward. No buyer or price has been named.
Billboard moratorium. Resolution 2026-38, on the consent agenda, would pause new off-premise billboards and electronic conversions for six months while the city updates its sign rules. It would be the city's seventh such moratorium since 2018.
Library grant. Acceptance of a $10,532.02 State Grants-in-Aid award from the New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs.
December schedule. Stockwell proposes merging the two December meetings into one on Dec. 8.
Residents who want to speak during public comment must sign up with the city clerk; the usual limit is three minutes. To sign up individuals must sign the list prior to 6:30.
The full agenda packet is posted on the city's website. For disability accommodations, call the City Clerk's Office at 575-439-4100 at least 48 hours ahead.
Alamogordo Town News will update this story with the commission's decisions after tonight's meeting.
Sources: Alamogordo Town News, "Alamogordo commission to weigh mayor's agenda role, closed-door complaint against city manager," Nov. 14, 2026; New Mexico Municipal League, The Municipal Reporter, "Ask a Clerk," 2025 issue, page 5.