Zero Shovels, $180K Salary: Alamogordo’s Gang of Four Stalls the Work
Broken Promises, High Salaries, and Zero Shovels: How the Gang of Four and a $180,000 Bureaucrat Are Starving Alamogordo’s Infrastructure and Driving Away the Workers Who Could Fix It
Alamogordo NM - For more than two years the Alamogordo City Commission staged a recruitment process that repeatedly delayed, derailed, and ultimately discarded a qualified local candidate who already held a Ph.D., had run the city successfully for roughly 28 months as acting manager, and had scored at the top of prior evaluations. In March 2026 the commission voted 7-0 to open contract negotiations with Dr. Stephanie Hernandez. Weeks later the same body reversed itself. A four-commissioner bloc—Josh Rardin, Stephen Burnett, Baxter Pattillo, and Al Hernandez—voted 4-3 to accept a settlement tied to an EEOC matter and end her tenure. They then installed Robert Stockwell, a former city manager the commission itself terminated by a 5-1 vote in 1997, through closed executive sessions and a consent-agenda path. The vote was 5-2. The process that produced him was neither the open national search the public was promised nor a transparent comparison of finalists.
Stockwell’s contract set a $180,000 base salary—above the range previously advertised and above the figures discussed for Hernandez—plus a $500 monthly vehicle allowance, immediate credit of 180 hours of paid time off, full benefits, and six months’ severance. First-year value exceeds $200,000; total compensation has been estimated in the $236,000–$242,000 range.
Recent permanent managers were paid far less: Brian Cesar roughly $130,000–$135,000, Maggie Paluch $120,000. The package was adapted from a draft employment agreement originally prepared for Hernandez, with her name struck through and Stockwell’s inserted, then sweetened. Commissioner Rardin later claimed the deal mirrored a 2012 interim consulting arrangement; city records show it does not.
Builders and developers were told the water-rate increases and new bond capacity would produce contracts, skilled jobs, and measurable growth.
Rates began rising in July 2024—the first increase since 2015—under a multi-year plan meant to support roughly $160 million in critical water and sewer repairs. Further adjustments followed in 2025.
The city locked in an initial roughly $28 million financing package.
The project list was concrete: tank rehabilitation, La Luz Reservoir work (infrastructure dating to 1914), citywide meter replacement, Granada Hills, the Alaska/Post Office district, Oregon Avenue Phase 2, White Sands Boulevard, and the Walker Road/Airport Road corridor—pipes and streets neglected for five to seven decades.
Under the prior acting administration those packages were described as shovel-ready or advancing, with engineering complete or nearly complete and funding identified. Oregon Phase 1, New York Avenue, 10th Street repairs, tank rehabs were already slotted and completed. But now nothing.
Under Stockwell the forward motion stopped.
He has publicly blamed prior design work and ordered staff to hold new projects until they are “really ready,” even while the same on-call engineering firms remain on the city’s payroll for the assignments in question.
Oregon Phase 2, Granada Hills, White Sands and 10th, Walker Road and related water-and-road packages that had been scheduled for bidding have been paused.
Mayor’s-office announcements later in 2026 still listed several of the same projects as ready for competitive bids in the coming months; those bids have not appeared. Residents have absorbed successive rate increases. The contracts, the local payrolls, and the visible street work have not followed.
Roads are much worse then they were even 6 months ago and no progress but certain commissioners ensure golf course improvements moved forward.
Local contractors who routinely perform comparable water, sewer, and paving work in Mescalero, Las Cruces, La Luz, and other nearby communities are left waiting or looking elsewhere.
Skilled crews and individual tradespeople are leaving Alamogordo for steadier employment.
When the city finally releases the backlog—if it does—the experienced local workforce that was supposed to execute the work may already be gone.
That is not economic development. It is a self-inflicted contraction: higher rates, idle capital, and a shrinking pool of people who know how to dig the trenches and lay the pipe.
Twenty-eight million dollars sits authorized. A bureaucracy headed by a city manager whose base pay alone is $180,000 has not converted that authorization into competitive bids or construction.
Closed-door executive sessions continue to shield performance reviews, settlements, and investigations from public view.
The four commissioners who engineered the leadership change—Rardin, Burnett, Pattillo, and Al Hernandez—own this failure and poor result.
They sold rate increases and bond capacity as the fuel for growth and good-paying local jobs. What the public has received is a higher-paid manager, delayed projects, lawsuits and settlements, and workers leaving town.
It is time the gang of four stops protecting the process and starts demanding results in the open.
Publish the closed door quarterly city manager evaluations. Release the records on why projects are held up.
Put the designed and financed water, drainage, and road projects to bid. Fix the infrastructure.
That is the only outcome that matches what Alamogordo was told it would get. Everything short of that is a broken promise financed by ratepayers who are still waiting for the work. The public is demanding answers and the public has grown impatient.
More News from Alamogordo
- Weather Delays then Los Lunas Outlasts Alamogordo 13-6 5A Quarterfinal Los Lunas held on for a 13-6 win over the No. 5 Tigers
- New Mexico’s 2026 “Blue Wave” Was Mostly a Republican Turnout Collapse Statewide midterm participation looked similar to 2022, but the partisan composition flipped — and the numbers in NM-2 show why